Cookies are required for login or registration. Please read and agree to our cookie policy to continue.

Newest Member: Omega2752

General :
Back to day one really? What kind of psychopath is she???

default

torso1500 ( member #83345) posted at 6:29 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

there's always a danger of jumping from frying pan into the fire. Just leaving (which is how I interpreted the advice) ... very possibly running away. Leaving with a goal in mind, probably not running away.

People who are being abused often face obstacles to forming a cohesive goal or view of their own situation while they remain present in the abusive environment. Yes some of the responders probably mean divorce or permanent ends beyond getting out, but is it really helpful to make arguments against the immediate suggestion to be done in the environment and GET OUT?!

Again this frying pan into the fire analogy comes across as accidental abuse enablement. What, exactly, is the "fire" other than effectively fearmongering and othering the option to get out of the abusive environment? In practice, requiring people in these situations to have a whole plan and some certain intellectual/emotional understanding before they leave results in people never getting out of abuse. The time to figure out the big picture when you are being abused is while you are out of the environment.

I can't believe you are seriously pushing back on this and setting goalposts for GETTING OUT OF ABUSE. I would hope getting people out of abuse would be agreed on here to be a nearer-priority goal to parsing out the infidelity situation, but maybe I am wrong.

posts: 110   ·   registered: May. 16th, 2023
id 8909617
default

 Gemmy (original poster member #86765) posted at 8:13 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I am not looking for permission to leave, nor am I looking for someone to talk me into staying. I am just trying to figure out how to keep breathing in a world where the happiest memories of my life have become instruments of torture.

I know intellectually that there is life after betrayal, and that others have crawled out of this kind of darkness to find peace again, but right now I cannot see past the rubble.

I am not standing at a crossroads casually weighing the pros and cons of divorce. I am standing in the smoking ruins of the only life I ever wanted, mourning a marriage, a history, a future, and a version of myself that is dead and gone while the only person I would have ever turned to for comfort is the very person holding the match.

There is no cruelty on earth quite like needing to be held by the person who destroyed you.

I appreciate every single one of you who has reached out in a season where I have felt utterly abandoned, because your voices have kept me tethered when I felt myself slipping away.

But I am no longer asking myself whether I can survive the pain of leaving, because staying has already cost me everything I recognize about myself.

I spent eighteen years building a life with the person I loved most in the world, I spent the last year bleeding out trying to save it, and now I am sitting here with tears streaming down my face, trying to find the strength to walk away from the very thing I spent my entire adult life trying to protect.

I didn't want another life, I didn't want another woman, and I didn't want to start over. I just wanted my wife, my family, and my fucking life back, and the most soul crushing part of all of this is finally accepting that no matter how hard I fight or how much I love, I can never have it back. I just can not believe she would or could do this to me again. FUCk.

Betrayed but trying to stand for the family. ME: 45 M DDay Oct.18 2025- April 2026 Two LTA EA/PA first 2 years second 1 year - 14 years apart.

posts: 209   ·   registered: Nov. 21st, 2025   ·   location: Ontario Canada
id 8909621
default

 Gemmy (original poster member #86765) posted at 8:14 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

Repeat post

[This message edited by Gemmy at 8:21 PM, Monday, November 16th]

Betrayed but trying to stand for the family. ME: 45 M DDay Oct.18 2025- April 2026 Two LTA EA/PA first 2 years second 1 year - 14 years apart.

posts: 209   ·   registered: Nov. 21st, 2025   ·   location: Ontario Canada
id 8909622
default

InkHulk ( member #80400) posted at 8:32 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I know the place you are in right now is darker and more painful than you could have imagined. It’s hard to believe it’s survivable. But on my life, I swear to you that it is. Worried about you.

I know you aren’t looking for permission, not sure you are even looking for advice. But add my voice to those hoping you’ll create space from her in the short term. You don’t have to make the ultimate decision if you don’t feel ready. But I think you need separation to recover.

People are more important than the relationships they are in.

posts: 2992   ·   registered: Jun. 28th, 2022
id 8909624
default

SeekingWhatever ( new member #87613) posted at 9:29 PM on Monday, November 16th, 2026

I spent eighteen years building a life with the person I loved most in the world, I spent the last year bleeding out trying to save it, and now I am sitting here with tears streaming down my face, trying to find the strength to walk away from the very thing I spent my entire adult life trying to protect.

I can't imagine the extent of the exhaustion you have to be feeling. It's temporary. You will recharge. For yourself, for your kids. I've seen your story unfold over the summer and now into autumn, and you have already done the hard part. Living like this was the hard part. Grieving is less hard than that. I'm not giving any advice, I promise. But if you know you're ready, you have all the strength you need and more. It's just temporarily depleted because it's being swallowed by having to survive all this cruelty. Anyone who has poured themselves into your life in the last year the way you have can build anything. All you need is to find solid ground.

I'm rooting for you so hard, and I'm so incredibly sorry you're here.

sure as the sun in your eyes / love always returns

posts: 14   ·   registered: Jul. 22nd, 2026
id 8909625
default

DRSOOLERS ( member #85508) posted at 9:27 AM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

Again this frying pan into the fire analogy comes across as accidental abuse enablement. What, exactly, is the "fire" other than effectively fearmongering and othering the option to get out of the abusive environment

We see far too much of this, and it is desperately depressing. At its core, it’s just a "better the devil you know" argument.

Why aim for better when leaving could theoretically lead to something worse? Think a remorseless cheater is bad? Well, you could end up with a serial killer! You already know you're miserable after years of abuse and extreme betrayal, yet you're told you might be even unhappier if you leave. The sheer lack of ambition in this mindset is deeply sad.

Then, in the very next breath, the same people will claim that fear isn't a valid motivator to reconcile—while simultaneously insisting that leaving is the "easy" way out. Something isn't adding up.

I can't believe you are seriously pushing back on this and setting goalposts for GETTING OUT OF ABUSE. I would hope getting people out of abuse would be agreed on here to be a nearer-priority goal to parsing out the infidelity situation, but maybe I am wrong.

You aren't even in the same ballpark as wrong.

Gemmy, from the little I know of you—and the beauty, wisdom, empathy, and intellect you have shown in your writing over this past year—please do not let fearmongering stop you from reclaiming your life. I have zero doubts that if you choose to leave, you can build an excellent life without this woman. In fact, I strongly believe you will be far happier without her.

She doesn't get it, and I doubt she ever will. Your choice comes down to this: put up with the trash you've been handed, lower your standards, and close yourself off emotionally so her repeated betrayals, lies, and manipulations no longer affect you—essentially choosing to live in willful ignorance—or begin the process of moving on without her.

Personally, I think you've got enough evidence to nail shut the coffin of her chances of truly reforming.

2017: Betrayed

2026: Happily married to a faithful partner in a relationship untouched by betrayal. Wishing you the same peace and happiness.

posts: 569   ·   registered: Nov. 27th, 2024   ·   location: Newcastle upon Tyne
id 8909648
default

WoodThrush2 ( member #85057) posted at 1:38 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

I know you wanted the life you thought you had. You wanted the woman you thought you had. The key phrase is..."thought you had".

The dream and vision of what you wanted does not have to be cast away altogether...only redirected.

I will offer a terribly impersonal analogy...use only for concept.

Suppose a person dreams of owning and enjoying a Classic Corvette. They find and buy one and become extremely attached. They enjoy it and add accessories and spend time with it. Two years down the road the person realizes the frame is utterly unsafe, being painted over skillfully by the slick salesman. They then find out the engine was infact swapped from a Ford truck and really had no business being in a Corvette. Last but not least, they find out the body of the vehicle is actually a 3D printed fake. The entire car is undrivable due to safely, and is really after all not a Corvette.

The owner is sad but comes to realize, they actually don't own a Corvette. Yet they hold the dream and are all the wiser in their pursuit of finding a real Corvette. Sure, the remember some of the sentimental times when they thought they really had one....they feel ashamed of all the friends they gave rides....telling them they were riding a classic Corvette.

But they focus forward and look to the day when they can give those friends a ride in their new and REAL Corvette.


As I said....I know this falls infinitely short of the interpersonal, deeply seeded connection you thought you had. The wounds are simply unspeakable. The only real place I can offer you true heart healing.... miraculous healing...is the person of Christ. The Bible says He is aquainted with our grief. I KNOW...KNOW...that He is absolutely in tune with every single pain your are enduring. And I know He can comfort you in a way that is unexplainable. Draw near Hurting Friend. 🙏

posts: 517   ·   registered: Jul. 29th, 2024   ·   location: New York
id 8909654
default

Shrug6645 ( new member #87446) posted at 2:29 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

I am so, so sorry Gemmy. I am crying as I read this. You don’t deserve this. No one deserves this amount of pain.

I don’t have much to add I suppose except that you are not alone in so much of what you expressed. I’m not sure if that helps at all, but I frequently feel so alone in this recovery, so hearing that others understand helps me sometimes.

Infidelity doesn't just nuke your present. It reaches backward in time and steals your past. You remember being so happy, so excited, so in love, only to find out you were entirely alone in that reality.

I didn't want another life, I didn't want another woman, and I didn't want to start over. I just wanted my wife, my family, and my fucking life back, and the most soul crushing part of all of this is finally accepting that no matter how hard I fight or how much I love, I can never have it back.

I 100% resonate with this. I know I could leave and rebuild. I know I am strong and could handle that. But I am stuck in grieving a life I never wanted to lose. No matter if I stay or go, my life has changed completely. It has been corrupted and it fucking sucks.

I am so sorry you are here.

posts: 13   ·   registered: Jun. 4th, 2026   ·   location: USA
id 8909657
default

Bigger ( Attaché #8354) posted at 3:55 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

For what it’s worth I don’t see Sisoon as encouraging you to stay in the marriage no matter what. If that were the case, I would think his advice just as stupid as those that encourage divorce no matter what, and my interactions with Sisoon don’t suggest he’s stupid. I read his advice as trying to evaluate and work onwards on your own personal recovery based on what you are dealing with. That "work" can either keep you in some attempted reconciliation, or it could lead you to ending your marriage.

The following is MY evaluation – and it’s only based on what I have read over the months in your threads and your posts:

You are clearly articulate. The way you write suggests you have a brain, understand words and can get your message across.
Yet is the message getting across? Your wife’s actions indicate EITHER that it’s not getting across OR that she doesn’t respect what you need. IMHO maybe your best next step might be to clarify that to yourself.

I want to share a personal experience: Years ago I was asked to talk to a 13 year old girl/relative whose mother was dying from cancer. Before talking to her, I had a meeting with the hospital priest, head-nurse and her doctor. I asked them if any of them had told the girl directly that her mom had terminal cancer, and if the words "die" or "death" had been used. Turns out they used phrases like "greener fields", "long sleep", "painless place", all nice words for the more brutal DEAD.
When I talked to the poor girl – who knew her mom was going to greener fields, out of pain, long sleep…, I used the more brutal and direct words like "your mom is dying, and it’s very likely she will die in the next 48 hours". For the girl this was a shock because those "nice" words hadn’t struck home. The directness made her finally understand the reality of the situation, the finality of what lay ahead, and enabled them to have time to prepare for the inevitable death.
It’s decades since, and the "girl" is now a mom herself, and her kids call me grandpa. She has thanked me for the directness, delivered in a compassionate and kind way, but with utter clarity.

Why mention this?
Can you tell yourself that the wordage you use to your wife regarding the urgency and necessity of her being truthful and accountable is clear? Like "I need the truth or I cant remain married to you" is a lot clearer than the more eloquent and wordier "I think keeping secrets might make our journey forwards in this marriage harder".

If you can tell yourself (and what you tell us has no relevance at all on this issue) that the message is clear then the next question should be if she understands the message.

That might best be confirmed by having her repeat what you stated and what the consequences of this trickle-truth will be. Noting vague, nothing unclear, no "maybe I won’t" but more "if A happens then B will happen".

Friend – if you think the message is clear, and if you think the message is understood… well… then it’s clear to ME that whatever you have been doing to-date isn’t working…

It’s fine if you are only venting here. This is a great place to vent.
But friend – if you are hoping for change, and you truly think she understands the message, is clear on the consequences and YET continues to lie… then don’t expect what you have been doing to-date to change anything.

It’s up to YOU to define what that change might be. It could be yet another serious talk where you do your best to confirm the message is received and understood, it could be filing for divorce, it could be accepting you have a crappy marriage and pretend to be inevitably stuck in it until junior goes to college or whatever. It’s totally your call. But don’t expect change in an unchanged environment.

"If, therefore, any be unhappy, let him remember that he is unhappy by reason of himself alone." Epictetus

posts: 14165   ·   registered: Sep. 29th, 2005
id 8909665
default

sisoon ( Moderator #31240) posted at 5:19 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

Gemmy,

The hardest part of healing for me was realizing that I was losing illusion after illusion. I think your posts describe the process, the difficulty, the sense of helplessness, the sense of need, etc., etc., etc. better than anything I've ever read.

The clarity of your writing makes me think you get 'it,' and that's why I keep thinking you're on a path that leads as directly as possible to healing. It's a painful path, especially so because your W has been a master illusionist, but the destination is well worth the effort.

*****

Thanks, Bigger. I'll give one more shot at getting my point across.

There's a difference between being passive and being intentional.

This is passive: 'I'm gonna do X because ... IDK ... I can't think of anything else to do, and it can't make my life worse than it already is anyway.'

This is intentional: 'I'm gonna do X because I think it might help me in this way.'

It's rare that just moving away from pain is helpful. IMO, it's always better to consider where one is going when one contemplates leaving.

This is not, 'Stick with the devil you know.' It's, 'Look before you leap.'

Similarly, there's a difference between 'Look at what my WS did to me' and 'This is what my WS did, and this is how I'm responding.'

The 1st sentence gives a lot of power to the WS. The 2nd keeps the power with the BS, where it belongs. There is, after all, nothing that can change what the WS did. The BS can control only their own response.

Focusing on what the WS did keeps the BS from figuring out how they'll respond and helps keep the BS locked into mistakenly thinking they have to choose between being a doormat and ending the relationship.

[This message edited by SI Staff at 5:21 PM, Tuesday, November 17th]

fBH (me) - on d-day: 66, Married 43, together 45, same sex ap
d-day - 12/22/2010 Recover'd and R'ed
You don't have to like your boundaries. You just have to set and enforce them.

posts: 32352   ·   registered: Feb. 18th, 2011   ·   location: Illinois
id 8909670
default

InkHulk ( member #80400) posted at 5:30 PM on Tuesday, November 17th, 2026

Years ago, a book came out called "Ready, Fire, Aim", it’s basic premise being don’t let the perfect become the enemy of the good. It remains controversial in my company, but some very respected leaders have advocated for it.
I see in Gemmy something I struggled with, having a hard time taking a single step when I couldn’t see with any clarity what the second or third might be. He’s a smart enough guy that he is almost certainly used to that kind of forecasting. And when you are in the smoke of the rubble and you can’t see your hand in front of your face, that can be paralyzing. Maybe all of us would agree that taking a next step that seems profitable for health and healing would be a good idea. And that it’s really hard to think that step wouldn’t involve some distancing from her. Get your balance back, and then make your choice on step 2. It’s not all or nothing.

People are more important than the relationships they are in.

posts: 2992   ·   registered: Jun. 28th, 2022
id 8909673
Cookies on SurvivingInfidelity.com®

SurvivingInfidelity.com® uses cookies to enhance your visit to our website. This is a requirement for participants to login, post and use other features. Visitors may opt out, but the website will be less functional for you.

v.1.001.20260728a 2002-2026 SurvivingInfidelity.com® All Rights Reserved. • Privacy Policy